Showing posts with label private practice midwifery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private practice midwifery. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

The politics of birth for the private midwife: A minefield from all directions



Being a private midwife can be a minefield, you never know what action will set of an explosion. We all know minefields are designed to destroy or disable.  This means you can have a varying degree of damage from slight, mediocre or catastrophic. Clearing minefields is a long, slow, time-consuming process, and there is no room for error, a bit like the life of a private midwife. There is no clear pathway every woman (case) presents another set of issues often a new battle or the same one revisited but it is the same minefield, you just pray that you don’t step on one and get damaged. You have to select your path carefully.
What is so infuriating; the level of bureaucracy that is required…. let me share a story or two…..you have a so called ‘low risk’ woman who wants a homebirth, she needs to be booked into hospital as a backup – this is required by several governing bodies, however the hospitals play ping pong with you – Hospital ‘A’ says ‘No’ this woman is ‘low risk’ she needs to birth in hospital ‘B’. Hospital ‘B’ tells you No ‘we don’t have the infrastructure’ to support a homebirth go to hospital ‘A’ and whilst this toing and froing is going on….. The woman is progressing through her pregnancy…..God help you if you have a problem…because everyone wants to pass the buck.... And in the meantime the Director General has resigned; there is a State election so the Minister of Health does nothing to assist you and no one in the dept. responds to your urgent requests for help……What is the private midwife to do? However if the private midwife is found to be lacking in some capacity the hammer falls very quickly and very hard…... There is just no equity in this at all…it seems that progress is ever so slow: however I am grateful for the help I do get from some corners  and without that this journey would not be worth it….  I am also thankful for the women for without them we would not be midwives and the breaking of new ground would not be possible.

On the other hand the minefield is the choice some women make: they choose for whatever reason to go outside any boundary the midwife has…outside of the scope of practice the midwife has, and each midwife has their own limits….. now the midwife can choose to accept that woman’s sole choice at her own personal risk… as there is nothing to protect that midwife when she works outside the boundary of the so called ‘low risk’, accept her documentation and sometimes that is not even enough – the woman is only wanting what she considers is in her best interest. However the midwife ends up having to defend themselves and this means $$$$$ in legal fees, even if the midwife did everything within her power. Who looks after the midwives best interest? Not the regulatory body, not the government and certainly not the AMA - The Midwife has too….because no one else will…. This is sad reflection of Midwifery practice in Australia – I for one am not prepared to risk my registration and pay out $$$$ in legal fees…. until the midwife is afforded protection as her counterparts in the UK and NZ the Australian private midwife is becoming are rare commodity and will become extinct.

I will end by saying I have had some wonderful experiences with women along this journey and every single one has taught me something about myself and pushed a boundary – I reflect on every experience and say ‘how can I make the next one better’. The major drawback is the political battle that each case brings in access to hospital, collaboration and the support required…. The burden of collaboration is tremendous….it is a one sided affair….every now and then you step on a landmine and you get damaged….. And you contemplate when will the damage be catastrophic and you pray it won’t be you and it won’t be today.

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Head on the chopping block – HOMEBIRTH:



Homebirth the hot topic: combine that with autonomy, women’s choice of place of birth no matter what the risk factor and you have an explosive cocktail and a subject that will divide a nation. There has been much written on this subject and sadly what is bringing it to the forefront again is term foetuses (babies) dying at home, with or without a health professional.

In 2009 there were 30,760 women giving birth in WA and the average age was 29.5yrs, the majority of women (98.8%) gave birth in hospital. Non Hospital births 1.2% including Born Before Arrival (BBA) (0.4%) and babies born at home (0.8%). The caesarean section rate was 33.3% (10,241) of the women recorded as having had a previous caesarean section 87.1% had a repeat section. What we need to be doing is reducing the caesarean section rate and concentrating on is promoting normal birth.

In 2010 WA had 245 homebirths, 203 occurred with the Community Midwifery Program and 42 homebirths with private practice midwives. We have 19 private practice midwives registered with the Health Dept and 5 eligible midwives.

This debate about homebirth revolves around less than 1% of women, not that I am suggesting that their views are not important; however there are 99% of women that need midwifery input to improve their birth experiences. It seems that a disproportionate amount of time is spent on homebirth in relation to the work that needs to be done to improve maternity services for all women.

I will start with my position as a midwife on the subject in the current Australian context;

Do I believe that women have the right to choose where and how to give birth? YES.

Do all women need a midwife throughout the continuum of pregnancy, birth and postnatal period? YES.

Should homebirth be an option for all women? The evidence shows that homebirth is safe for uncomplicated pregnancies.

Should all women have a midwife? YES

Should high risk women birth at home supported by a midwife? This is the six million dollar question; professionally and personally I would answer NO, based on the lack of protection for the midwife to facilitate this choice. However it is not that simple; usually women who are choosing homebirth for high risk pregnancies have experienced some sort of birth trauma, are extremely fearful of hospital and usually have knowledge of the associated risks, each case needs to be evaluated individually. It is unfair to label all these women as zealots or radical. What needs to happen is to listen to what the issues are and find more flexible ways to support these women providing continuity of midwifery care, collaboration with an obstetrician within a safe health system.

What is a problem is if midwives / or de-registered midwives keep supporting high risk homebirth without collaboration and health service support. Recently there have been several high risk homebirth deaths. If the term fetus (babies) keeps dying in the homebirth setting we will be endangering homebirth for uncomplicated pregnancies. Worse still women will lose their autonomy because the term foetus will be afforded more rights similar to what has happened in the USA. Currently in Australia a foetus has no rights under law until born alive, but this concept is being challenged.

What needs to happen is that health services need to be more flexible, by having visiting rights for private practice midwives allowing them to bring their women into hospital and continue to caring for them. When fearful women present they should be facilitated to birth in a low risk setting such as a secondary hospital or birth centre supported by the tertiary hospital. Specialist obstetricians could travel to see the women and support the secondary hospital – it is about being flexible – considering the psycho-social issues of the women. Having all high risk women being herded into a hospital like cattle is giving them no choice or options therefore creating more fear. Remembering there is established legal principle that a mentally competent woman can refuse treatment. It is no wonder that these women choose to birth at home or freebirth. Freebirth is an unsafe and unacceptable practice and Health Services are failing women if this is the only option they feel they have.

We as midwives need some sort of supervision or mentoring system to support us in difficult clinical situations therefore allowing us to support these women. We need legislative changes to protect the midwife to stay with women no matter what the risk and where she chooses to birth, we need health services to be more flexible and supportive. We need women to be demanding that Health Services and Doctors be flexible, it’s about open communication and negotiation.

Three questions:

What do you think about the homebirth debate?
Would you have a high risk birth at home?
Would you freebirth?



Ref: WA Mothers and Babies 27th Annual Report – Midwives Notification System
photo credit: http://offthebroiler.wordpress.com/2006/11/21/death-of-a-turkey/

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Challenging times for women and midwives (HBAC)



Sad and disturbing times for both women and midwives:

As a private practice midwife it is very important to understand the boundaries of my role as a midwife; some are outlined in my previous blog “government paying us lip service”. Many midwives are facing complex ethical dilemmas:
As a UK trained midwife I was used to being able to do a homebirth for a woman who has risk factors and has had collaboration and consultation with an obstetrician through the local Health Authority and has chosen a homebirth despite these risk factors. The difference being that in the UK there is a Supervision system of midwives (supervisor of midwives) that provides midwives with support and backup. Also within the UK system you are protected by legislation that states that only a midwife or a doctor can assist with the birth except for an emergency in which case anyone can help.

S16 (1) A person other than a registered midwife or a registered medical practitioner shall not attend a woman in childbirth: Nurses Midwives and Health Visitors Act 1997(UK)

In the UK a woman’s choice is respected in that she can birth at home and the local Health Authority has to provide a midwife for the homebirth if one is available (National Health Services Act). Also the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (RCOG) and Royal College of Midwives have a Joint Statement No.2. -April 2007 supporting homebirth and work together to support this. However here in Australia a major problem is that the AMA categorically opposes Homebirth.

The Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) works in the same way as AHPRA in its role to protect the public to ensure that midwives work within their scope of practice which is low risk ‘normal’ and provide a safe environment for birthing women. Independent Midwifery is also under threat in the UK as there is no insurance for private practicing midwives: see Homebirth and the Law reference list: http://www.homebirth.org.uk/law.htm

The Health System is different in Australia; therefore we cannot really compare with the UK except to say that both regulatory authorities work in the same way, in protecting the public and ensuring that midwives provide safe and competent care for the woman.

Legal Advice: I am not a lawyer and not giving legal advice; this is my interpretation of the legal advice given to me)

I have to state that my position as a midwife is that yes I believe in “women having choice in place of birth” and I believe that every woman should have midwifery care. I also have to state that I believe my role as a midwife is dealing with the “normal” and anything that falls outside of the parameters of “normal” I will collaborate with an Obstetrician, working in partnership with the woman to achieve a mutual arrangement and provide midwifery care throughout. I would like to see more liberal / flexibility surrounding place of birth for high risk women instead of always sending women to tertiary centres where they often feel alienated and fearful this would be a step in the right direction.

In light of the recent debate surrounding HBAC, I have sort some legal advice regarding the issue of VBAC (vaginal birth after caesarean) and having a homebirth. I wanted to know where I stood legally when a woman approaches me as a midwife asking for this service, should I decide to book a planned homebirth for H/VBAC – in terms of my responsibilities and my registration/licence: You have to remember that a good lawyer can argue a defence for anything and there is always a defence to be had.

The first question you have to ask is - What does the professional bodies say about HBAC / VBAC?
The professional bodies are the AMA and ACM – (the AMA has 90% membership, do not support homebirth, and is very powerful & political) does this give you an idea of what the answer will be to the first question.

Second question: What does the regulatory body stipulate about HBAC/ VBAC? Here you have to look at the current codes and guidelines that govern midwifery practice; you could compare with the UK, NZ and USA;

Thirdly : Have you provided unbiased informed choice, have you got collaboration (Dr; support) for the H/VBAC is it clearly documented, have you clearly documented the risks associated with HBAC/ VBAC , are you providing a safe environment for the woman; and have you an emergency care plan, are you working within your scope of practice?

There may be a possible defence, how successful this would be is the unknown quantity as it has not been tested yet and I can assure you I am not going to be the first to do this.

Women do have a choice of place of birth; however the choice to have a midwife present in the home environment for a risk associated birth is a limited option due to the legislation and the regulatory authority. However if the midwife chooses to accept the HBAC he/she maybe risking disciplinary action which could mean losing his/her registration and or having restrictions on his/her practice together with a lengthy legal case that will be distressing and costly.

How to move forward:
The answer is to work on changing legislation, to something similar to the UK and gaining support from the AMA to collaborate with midwives in listening to what women want. Helping and facilitating women achieve the kind of birth they want in a safe environment with a health professional to support them, whether that is in hospital or the home. Providing different models of care which include continuity of care no matter what the risk factor is.

It is very clear that the consumer/woman has to lead the impetus for change, the demand must come from them otherwise nothing will change; it is the power of the voter to change legislation.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The government is paying us lip service:


There are three burning issues for me currently: Mandatory reporting, women’s choice to birth where and how they want and ‘continuity of midwifery care’; each deserves a separate blog.

I have refrained from blogging recently because things have been politically difficult and I have been trying to keep a low profile, but it hasn’t worked, so I might as well just carry on and express my opinions.

I am in a real quandary as with many midwives, there is a fine line we walk and I have erred on the side of caution and to no avail. What keeps me on the straight and narrow is the fact that I value my registration. That is not to say I don’t value the woman’s choice, but if that choice compromises my registration I will think very carefully about the consequences before making a decision.

Up until recent times this has not presented a problem, however since the introduction of the new legislation namely the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (WA) 2010. With this legislation came mandatory reporting, if I had known the implications of this piece of legislation I would have fought harder to see it changed. I had no idea until it started happening, that is the reporting of midwives. This is not about pitting midwife against midwife; this legislation is about ‘mandatory reporting’ the same as ‘mandatory reporting’ for child abuse...... it is the law and if you don’t there are consequences for not doing so ( it is noted that there are no penalties prescribed under the National Law for practitioners who fail to notify, but you may be subject to conduct or performance action)....Most reports have been made by Health Services or Medical Practitioners, however it is interesting to note that it seems that only midwives are being reported using this clause: s140(d)
s.140 of the National Law defines ‘notable conduct’ as where a practitioner has; (a).., (b).., (c)..., (d) placed the public at risk of harm because the practitioner has practised the profession in a way that constitutes a significant departure from accepted professional standards.’
The explanation given in the AHPRA document Guidelines for mandatory notifications (p4)
The term ‘accepted professional standards’ requires knowledge of the professional standards that are accepted within the health profession and a judgement about whether there has been a significant departure from them.
The notifiable conduct of the practitioner must have placed the public at risk of harm as well as being a significant departure from accepted professional standards before a notification is required. However, the risk of harm just needs to be present - it does not need to be a substantial risk, as long as the practitioner’s practice involved a significant departure from accepted professional standards. For example, a clear breach of the health profession’s code of conduct which placed the public at risk of harm would be enough.

Maybe we should start reporting doctors for placing the public at risk by overzealous reasons for caesarean sections, or rupturing membranes when it’s not required, or induction of labour for social reasons. I am sure there are many reasons doctors give that are unfounded and put the public at risk. Why are health services or midwives not reporting doctors for unsafe practice or out of scope practice as readily as they are reporting midwives, there seems to be a real disparity in the reporting mechanism.
If hospitals are going to use this piece of legislation then use it fairly on all health practitioners not just midwives, this is paramount to a witch-hunt we have moved back 20yrs, why not just burn us at the stake.

Our problem lies with the legislation, it is the law and this is what needs to be addressed to resolve some of these issues. Australia currently has no protection for midwives who choose to support the woman's choice of care which falls outside of the recommended standard of care - a midwives role is "normal" - I can hear all the rhetoric.

Choice:
It seems that women do not have choice; choice seems to be relative to the situation or dependent on certain conditions – if your BMI remains normal, if your glucose level stays low, if you don’t have a scar on your uterus etc etc,. Working within frameworks is not something new for midwives and balancing the woman’s autonomy against these frameworks can be difficult and often puts the midwife in a stressful position which may lead to an inquiry and threats of negligence.

Informed choice is a fundamental issue, autonomy the right to self determination – not when it comes to health and perceived risk. Mavis Kirkham states that ‘in our own culture, obstetric ideology is particularly coercive. The medical definition of safety and risk means that while minor choices exist, conceptual choices cannot.’
“.......You can have your baby any way you like as long as you understand that I must step in when the safety of you and the baby is involved’ (Shelley Romalis 1985 p 190). How many times have you heard this?

The women the consumer must stand up and demand what is rightfully theirs, the right to birth where and how they want and protection for the midwife who cares for that woman’s choice.

The gloves are off, because I think the government is paying us as midwives lip service. Since November 1 2010, we have seen many changes, Medicare rebates, eligibility and insurance for midwives; however the maternity reforms certainly in WA are lacking in substance and commitment from the State government.



ref:Informed Choice in maternity care: Edited by Mavis Kirkham (2004)

Saturday, March 19, 2011

The art of being patient: Centred Midwifery Group Practice:


The Centred Midwifery Group Practice....it's interesting for me,in my mind the vision of the practice is a complete success, it flows smoothly and seems easy.... however the reality is somewhat different there are so many other variables involved to which I have no control. Yes that might be naive of me or it could be that the vision I have is so strong that it propels me to do the things I do... However the truth is that this is going to be a long slow process and I need to rethink the way forward in terms of my sustainability and how we are going to get collaboration working.... as my friends, colleagues and family keep telling me that “Rome was not built in a day” and it has taken us 20 years to get Medicare rebates for midwives.... a valued colleague said yesterday “ you are going to fall on your bottom and few times...the trick is to get back up and keep going,” “why are you surprised?” ......The answer is that I have a vision and the vision doesn’t have the stonewalls..........

The story thus far: The Group Practice has a brilliant dedicated team or midwives/consumers working to build the practice: We owe Berry Digital Design(Cass) an enormous Thank you she has done all our logo designing flyers, business cards / letterheads/invoices/receipts etc, printing and all pro bono...I highly recommend her so check out her website: if you want any designing or printing done. We have our email x6 is setup secretary@centredmgp.com and director@centredmgp.com the website and blog is coming as I type... so watch this space.....Our rooms are at the Conscious Conception and Birth Centre and we are now setting up the office with equipment: if anyone has a phone fax and photocopier/computer they would like to donate please let me know: Medicare provider number obtained, Insurance paid, pathology and diagnostic rights have all been secured and we are working on collaborative arrangements with the local Health Service..... this will take time: Most importantly we are starting to get clients and this is what keeps us going.... our practice is about offering women choice the choice to birth with a known midwife.... continuity of midwifery care....it’s about having time to talk to women, engage and build trusting relationships with women and their family throughout pregnancy birth and the postnatal period...


It is an exciting process setting up a new midwifery group practice in WA....
The next step is to go and visit the local hospitals, MP’s and GP surgeries to introduce the Practice and rally up support.... go to consumer meetings and get the word out there.....and last but not least advertising for clients....... it really is very exhilarating watching it all coming to fruition.
We need more midwives to pick up eligibility..... if you are an experienced midwife and want to work with women in the community, that is at home and hospital births please consider this option....contact me for more information about the process that is required for eligibility it’s not difficult you just need three years post registration working across the continuum of midwifery: or visit the AHPRA website and follow the links to eligibility:

As for me.... it is practising the art of patience’s....slowly, slowly, slowly..... Diplomacy and political lobbying; continue meditation... this has really proven helpful in slowing my mind chatter and keeping a calm demeanour...
Watch this space for our grand opening...... date coming soon......

Friday, January 28, 2011

The question is do you use a partograph or not?



The partograph or partogram graphically represents key events in labor and provides an early warning system for the health professional caring for the woman. Until recently I had not given this much thought, I just accepted as part of my practice. I would use a partograph as part of my normal care in labour. I do notice when I go to different hospitals how they all vary slightly. Some are just cumbersome, some not practical and some just down right difficult to use......... and as for that action line....that is a different question all together... I would happily use a partograph without the action line...because part of my normal practice is to know that if the woman is at 4cm and contracting well (3-4:10) then her cervix is dilating and I would make a mental note that in 6 hours I would expect to being seeing signs of being fully dilated.

I understand possibly the need for a partogram in the hospital setting when you have several people looking at the notes; therefore there needs to be a quick review process. However in a home setting you are the only person as well as your partner midwife looking at the notes...so I question the value of using a partogram:

As I was doing a search on the web looking for a partograph template, I found lots of literature supporting the use of the partograph and the action line in preventing or recognising obstructed labour. In fact The World Health Organization partographs are the best known partographs in low resource settings. Some people argue the partograph is essential for good decision making.....and therefore is considered best practice...

A midwife is legally bound to document to clearly / comprehensively all our care, recognise / interpret /act / inform on abnormalities found in a timely fashion however does this mean she/he has to use a partogram to do this?

I am thinking that it is not necessary to use a partogram in the home setting if your documentation clearly tells the story.

What do you think?

can you write your notes in a fashion that does not need a visual expression of what is occurring? and does it make a difference using a partogram?

please leave me a comment on what you think?

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Insurance for Midwives:

Now that I have a Medicare Provider number & eligibility it's time to consider my insurance; the options that midwives have are:
A government supported insurance through MIGA (The Medical Insurance Group) or Mediprotect insurance;

The question you have to ask is which insurance do you choose? here is all the information: an important factor to consider is which company offers run-off-cover:

Read MIGA information Booklet:
Frequently asked questions:
Payment options:
Risk Managment workshops:
Maternity Care Plans & Collaboration
Product disclosure Statement:Application form:


Mediprotect - Vero - wording of policy document:
Application form:

As you can see from the summary of information available.. there is more information provided by MIGA than Mediprotect:

The most important factor for me is, I need intrapartum cover when birthing in a hospital as a private practice midwife and run off cover; therefore my choice of insurance will be governed by this; I have therefore applied with MIGA and will see how much my costs will be, although I have a good idea of what it will be.......

I have also sort guidance from my accountant and lawyer.....so that I am fully aware of my requirements.....it is exciting times....

Friday, January 21, 2011

Medicare Provider Number:


At last I have my Medicare Provider Number.... yeah...First eligibility,(see blog how to apply for eligibility) then Medicare Number and Insurance... all set to go.... website, business cards, flyers, something is missing.... yes the "women" wanting continuity of midwifery care.... I have booked my first woman.... and so life goes on... poor Ian is wondering how we are going to pay for the insurance......???

Applying for a Medicare Provider Number is relatively easy, however I have to say for WA applications are not processed here they are sent to Canberra so might take a few extra days for this reason..... interestingly you have to provide a signed form for every address that you will be working from and you will receive a provider number for each location.... for example if I was to work out of two officers, I would give each address and for a home visit I will use my home address as the office... therefore potentially you could have several address and provider numbers...

I have sent my application for my MIGA insurance today... and hopefully that will take a week or so to sort out and then I am set to go.....this is an interesting journey.... a brave new world....

Friday, December 24, 2010

First Eligiable Midwife for WA:


At last on my return from Tanzania I received a letter from AHPRA (16th Dec) that they had met on the 2nd December and have approved my application:


"An eligible midwife competent to provide pregnancy, labour, birth and post natal care and qualified to provide the associated services and order diagnostic investigations required for midwifery practice. In accordance with relevant State and Territory legislation.

Eligible midwife, but NOT qualified to obtain endorsement under section 94 to prescribe Schedule 2, 3, 4 & 5 medicines required for midwifery practice in accordance with State and Territory legislation".


It goes without saying that all midwives once you have successfully completed your course are by definition eligible midwives, we just have another criteria to get now for legislation and that is "eligibility" (three years experience post registration across the full scope of midwifery).... see the AHPRA website for more information.
A notation goes on the public register so that anyone can see if you are eligible or not.....
Next step is applying for a MBS provider number, I will be doing this between Christmas and the New Year;
One of next year's plan is to complete the Prescribing and Diagnostic courses....which are not up yet.....but will start following this up... Roll on the New Year..... NOW come on all you WA midwives start applying for eligibility:

ref pic: henry.k12.ga.us

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Centred Midwifery Group Practice Inc (CeMGP)



Wow it is official….this has been a dream of mine for some time and became a reality today when the Dept of Commerce called me today to confirm our application for incorporation was successful. We are the first private Midwifery Group Practice for WA this is a huge step. I am so proud this is a fantastic achievement. We are a fantastic team of dedicated Midwives;

This idea has been mulling around in my head since returning to WA 7 years ago… however it is only since the Maternity Reform has the idea become a reality…. Women being able to access Medicare Rebates for midwifery services.

In July 2010 I talked about the idea, shared with a few people and in August asked a group of equally passionate women to come on board with this concept…..We met at my home for a day workshop and nutted out some key ideas…. One of which was the name Centred Midwifery Group Practice (CeMGP). I will not blog today the story from then till now I will save that for future blogs…. This is to share our fantastic news and say we are here….. watch this space…..for our Website, Facebook page and blog...all being designed as I type....

Our Philosophy: “We put you at the centre of your experience”. We are group of committed midwives, dedicated to providing safe, competent, continuity of care, individualised and professional midwifery care and support to the well woman and her baby throughout pregnancy, birth and early parenthood.

I am so excited I can hardly contain myself.... this is so huge it is a dream come true......more to come in the coming days.....this is just the beginning...... of a wonderful fruitful experience with women and birth.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

A bottle of Red......frustration of midwifery;


I had a bottle of red...with my husband, I am trusting him to proof read this blog as I feel positively tipsy ; I have had a bad day....a meeting from hell ego’s present in the room; I feel disempowered in my current position... people not being honest with their intentions.... all it takes is open honest discussion; and a colleague received some bad news that is really unfair.... why does life have to be so unfair; I really feel that we as a profession get the rough end of the stick.....I pride myself on integrity and honesty... I get so frustrated with women who do not stand up for women’s rights (but I guess this is dependent on your point of view) and maybe everyone thinks their point of view is correct...it truly is a man’s world and when we get women in power they seem to think the most important thing is to be accepted by men...that means playing by the man’s rule..... I am really feeling for a colleague of mine who I have grown to know on a intimate basis and trust her judgement and skill as a midwife I am really saddened that situation has not worked out for her as I had hoped and with my knowledge and expertise I have not been able to help her and for that I am truly sorry. All I have to say is as long as midwives are not protected by law we are open to the rules of nurses and we are very different.

Midwives need legislation to protect them to truly ‘be with woman’. Managers who are managing midwives need to be a midwife to really understand the issues that midwives face.... ideally they also need to understand what homebirth is about and the reality of choices women make at a homebirth; this problem highlights that nurses do not understand the autonomy and bond midwives have with women....... I guess a bottle of red will allow you to say almost anything I am distressed for my colleague that life has turned out this way... and even after a bottle of red it doesn’t stop the pain of what she is feeling... and there for the Grace of God go I..... here I am about to embark on a huge adventure for women and midwifery and I wonder if it is all worthwhile, because in one instant it can all be gone...we work so hard as a midwife to advocate for women.....to facilitate their choice.... but alas in Australia there is no protection for the midwife if things go wrong...and yes babies do die.. ..often despite our best efforts and for reasons beyond our control...errors are made because we are human but they are made every day in a hospital and babies die in hospital .....that is the process of life... we do our best to reduce the errors or mistakes;

We know that we are medically dominated that it is really unacceptable....however for this to change...it needs women to stand up and be counted... if you want the birth you want then you need to say so.... stand up and tell the medical profession this is what you want.... it is only in women’s voices will you be heard and midwives can then facilitate what you want; women have the power......you only have to say....


As for my colleague I am sorry.... you have to fight to the end degree... ..For what you believe in.... as for me...I will strive to be the best I can... I am thankful for my family that supports me...even though it takes so much time away from them and to my friends...thank you for keeping me on the straight and narrow... I have to learn to stop wearing my heart on my sleeve...feeling the pain of others: Also take more time out from all these pressures;

....I will continue to do the greater good for women and midwifery.... the end result is a Midwives Act to support the choice of women and protect the midwife.....well the bottle of red is finished my husband my lovely husband has stopped me from the second bottle.... wow he is wondering what has hit him........ I have to say drinking does not solve any problems but hell, I sure felt good for a short while;

It is the next day; I have substantially edited this blog... and am very thankful I did not post it last night.....surprisingly I did not sleep well, my liver was objecting to the alcoholic abuse it received; Today I have drunk a litre of water with two paracetamol. I have to say that this is a rare occurrence drinking a bottle of wine, usually it is only a glass or two on the weekend.

I am reflective and still wondering how to take this issue further; and my husband cannot stop laughing at me:

A new day begins and the journey continues;

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Time for Medicare Provider Numbers; it has only taken 24yrs


On the weekend I was in Melbourne and I was fortunate to hear this piece of information which made me sit up and think.... has much changed over 24yrs?..and if we miss this chance will it take another 24yrs?

The information comes from " COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA MEDICARE BENEFITS REVIEW COMMITTEE (2ND REPORT) JUNE 1986 p 230;
Submissions concerning midwifery were received from the National Midwives Association the Royal Australian Nursing Federation, the New South Wales Nurses Association, the Launceston North Coast Home Birth Support Group and numerous Private individuals. ......Most of the submissions proposed that midwife be recognised on an equal footing with medical practitioners in respect of the payment of Medicare benefits for certain services associated with uncomplicated birthing........of the many medical and paramedical issues raised with this committee, the question of the payment of registered midwives generated the greatest depth of paramedical submissions addressed 25% were midwifery related......

Has much changed in 24 years..... we are on the brink of change.


Some midwives are confusing the Medicare Provider Number with the requirement of insurance. However the issue of insurance is a requirement of National Registration s129(1)registered health practitioner must not practise the health profession in which the practitioner is registered unless appropriate professional indemnity insurance arrangements are in force in relation to the practitioner's practice of the profession.

In order to have a Medicare Provider Number you need to be an eligible midwife... Have a look on the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Board site to remind you what these requirements are;

The Health Insurance (Midwife and Nurse Practitioner) Determination 2010; for the Medicare Provider Numbers... check out the determination; the Midwifery services and fees range from $31.10 -$724.00 also is included 6 weeks of postnatal care...which is excellent for women and will also help provide greater postnatal care....

This is the beginning of new things, an opportunity of greater access for all women... however we must remember that unfortunately this does not include homebirth...therefore we need to more than ever keep the pressure on the government.. to pass this service fee onto women who choose a homebirth.....

Monday, September 20, 2010

Would you throw out the baby with the bath water?


Currently midwives particularly homebirth private practice midwives are up in arms (and rightly so) about the recent Determination where Midwives are to be virtually signed of by doctors. That is as a privately practicing midwife (independent) you need to collaborate with an Obstetrician or GP obstetrician before being able to claim a Medicare rebate for the midwifery services provided. I might add that there is nothing in the Determination to make doctors collaborate with midwives or any benefit for doctors to collaborate.... so I am not sure why they would even consider it as we (midwives) would be competition for them in terms of financial remuneration therefore less money in their pockets..... emm not sure this will work?

If you are a midwife this seems a sort of sellout, Medicare for collaboration; However the woman is able to recoup some funds with this system therefore allowing more women this option of care....that is continuity of midwifery care and also midwifery led care;

Now as I see it there are two schools of thought......

1: If the government does not change the wording of the current determination; you go all out and say no to collaboration as it stands therefore we lose the right to a Medicare rebate and the legislation falls over; and we maintain the status quo as in the past which is no funding or rebates for women choosing private practice midwifery led care.... and it does not go before Parliament again for three years.... and if the government changes we may never have this opportunity for a long long time.... we will still have insurance requirements and regulations, that will not change.

or

2: we say yes to the collaboration as it stands, work to make it a viable option and see how and if it would work and if it does not work we then collate the evidence and go back to the politicians to lobby for changes to the determination knowing it does not work, rather than speculating that it does not work....therefore whilst we are battling for change women are able to claim a Medicare rebate for midwifery services? and Midwives are recognised for the profession that it is... which should have a medicare provider number.....and be recognised as autonomous clinicians.

Once the system (Medicare) whether it is effective now or not would be beneficial as we can work on changes....but if we never get it in place it will be years before we get back to this position and all our work up to this point would be for nothing as would of achieved nothing and the status quo remains.

What would you do in this situation?

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Working as an Private Practice Midwife with the new legislation:


As from the 1st July 2010 all of Australia except for WA has joined National Registration (AHPRA) and therefore requiring indemnity insurance when registering as a Midwife, or Nurse Practitioner. WA is expecting to join National Registration in mid October 2010, until then the Nurses and Midwives Act 2006 applies.

There are a few ways in which this can be achieved in Australia with the new Collaborative Arrangements: If you are already in private practice/independent you can use the exemption clause from the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 s284 (Exemption from requirement for professional indemnity insurance arrangements for midwives practising private midwifery)

During this time the midwife does not contravene section 129(1) which states you need private indemnity insurance to be registered. However the midwife must ensure that he/she has a signed consent form from the woman in relation to having no insurance. However you need to be mindful of 284(1)(c)i “the midwife complies with any requirements set out in a code or guideline about reports to be provided by midwives practising private midwifery; and(ii) any requirements in a code or guideline relating to the safety and quality of the practise of private midwifery.
Codes to note: New Code of Ethics for Midwives August 2008: New Code of Professional Conduct for Midwives August 2008: Midwifery Competency Standards August 2008:

In simple terms you can continue to practice as an independent/private practice midwife and the women you are looking after will pay for your services as per normal and will not be able to claim a Medicare rebate. As per normal you are advised to keep exemplary notes about the care you have provided and audit your practice and outcomes, so when it is time in two years to apply for Homebirth insurance midwives will have the data to prove that homebirth has good outcomes and is cost effective.
Registration standard for Eligibility: to claim MBS and PBS you will need to be an ‘eligible’ midwife, this means three years experience in the continuum of midwifery care. Completion of further studies relating to pharmaceutical and diagnostic investigations and 20 hours of continuing professional development per year.

National health (Collaborative arrangements for midwives) Determination 2010 – National Health Act 1953 – this document outlines the collaborative arrangements for midwives – basically this document states that midwives have to collaborate (although we already do this and is part of our competency standards) – consultation between the midwife and an obstetric specified medical practitioner, referral of women to a specified midwife, or the midwife is employed or engaged by 1 or more obstetric practitioners or an ‘entity’ that employs obstetricians. The Arrangement – midwife’s written record..... this actually means that you have to enter into a written arrangement that both parties agree to about the care of the woman.....strangely enough there is no provision in this document for what the woman may want here...because if the woman chooses something outside the sphere of the realms of normal the midwife will not be able to continue the care because she will probably not have the support of the obstetrician therefore will not be collaborating and the woman is left stranded...... now what do we do...and herein lies the problem........ with having the medical model trying to control midwives.

At this point in time there is nothing that we can do about this Determination..... the horse has bolted......(a determination is allowed or disallowed) nothing will go forward until after the election.....My fear is that with a Liberal government we will go backwards, there is a slim chance with the labour government that we may be able to amend this document however the Greens are showing more positive support for our plight with this unworkable document.... As a midwife I want to be able to offer women the choice of birthing at home without having to have an obstetrician sign off my care..... I am a professional and know my boundaries, I work within my codes.

I see the way forward as lobbying the government to change this determination by having a strategy of safe clinical care, auditing homebirth and outcomes, peer review and supervision process and risk management strategies...without having to have my care signed off by a Dr...... not to mention the cost effectiveness of midwifery led care as opposed to hospital base care. We need to lobby the government find out who you local MP is and send them an email or letter:

“Hi, I am ………………….., my address is ………………and I live in (your electorate’s name). I would like to let you know that I am concerned with the recent determination passed by the ALP government - the National Health (Collaborative arrangements for midwives) Determination 2010. Midwives already collaborate with medical colleagues but I don’t want them to have to enter a “collaborative arrangement” or any kind of signed agreement with a doctor for the purpose of getting Medicare. I also want all maternity care policies to have the right to informed choice (right of refusal) written in to them. I want a long term solution so that women always have an ability to access homebirth care and I want national visiting access to public hospitals for all eligible midwives.”

It is time to be politically active.......contact your local MP and find out what their position is!

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Collaborative arrangements for Midwives:


Well; after a long awaited time we finally know what the collaborative arrangements are.....I must say I am disappointed...after lots of negotiation I feel let down and that the machinery of money, politics and power have yet again trampled on the profession of midwifery.

The other issue is the upcoming election; we are in a crucial stage....Labour stays so does the current status quo...Liberal in and we lose it all....I do think that NICOLA ROXON Minister for Health and Ageing has tried to do the best for Midwives and also trying to accommodate the AMA.....without losing any ground and yes she too has to protect her position so that Labour remains in power.

This document is hard to read, you need to read it several times to work out exactly what it is saying.
For example if you read this section:
Specified medical practitioners
For the definition of authorised midwife in subsection 84 (1) of the Act, the
following kinds of medical practitioner are specified:
(a) an obstetrician;
(b) a medical practitioner who provides obstetric services;
(c) a medical practitioner employed or engaged by a hospital authority and authorised by the hospital authority to participate in a collaborative
arrangement.

First impression is that an independent midwife or private practice midwife cannot practice without having an obstetrician sign them off..... however (c) indicates that any hospital doctor can act as an collaborative partner...therefore the hospital will act as an collaborative partner....

Now if we look at section 7: this part is more hopeful in that if we get a hospital to support private practice this will work as collaborative arrangement: we could extend it to domino births.....the problem with all this collaborative how much is truly required.... if everything is normal then there needs to be no collaboration....and yes...there has to be a hospital booking which will mean collaboration with a doctor...at least once..but thereafter you would not see the doctor again if everything is normal....and this is as it should be.....

Arrangement — midwife’s written records
(1) An eligible midwife must record the following for a patient in the midwife’s
written records:
(a) the name of at least 1 specified medical practitioner who is, or will be,
collaborating with the midwife in the patient’s care (a named medical
practitioner);(b) that the midwife has told the patient that the midwife will be providing midwifery services to the patient in collaboration with 1 or more
specified medical practitioners in accordance with this section;
(c) acknowledgement by a named medical practitioner that the practitioner
will be collaborating in the patient’s care;


If doctors truly were collaborative they would be referring more women to our current Birth Centers, but they do not because they want the control and money.... It is hard to even imagine that doctors will refer to the midwife....for normal care...because they do not even believe in Birth Centres.... how will they make this massive change when they do not even support homebirth.....?
I would like to see that they are made to refer women to midwives... instead of the old school boy tie club and kick backs to specialists.....

The bottom line is, it's the women's choice....it is about continuity of care and that every woman needs a midwife.

Keep focused on the dream, the passion and the right of women to choose where they want to birth their babies, the right to informed choice and the right to have a midwife.

Click on this link:
National Health (Collaborative arrangements for midwives) Determination 2010

Sunday, June 13, 2010

Eligible Midwife Australia.....this is what it looks like


The Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia has submitted to the Ministerial Council for approval: the Registration Standard for Eligible Midwife and Registration for Endorsement for Scheduled Medicines for Eligible Midwives.

What does this mean for the average midwife in Australia?
Requirements
To be entitled to be identified as an eligible midwife, a midwife must be able to demonstrate, at a minimum, all the following:

Current general registration as a midwife in Australia with no restrictions on practice;

Midwifery experience that constitutes the equivalent of 3 years full time post initial registration as a midwife;

Current competence to provide pregnancy, labour, birth and post natal care to women and their infants;

Successful completion of an approved professional practice review program for midwives working across the continuum of midwifery care;

20 additional hours per year of continuing professional development relating to the continuum of midwifery care;

Formal undertaking to complete within 18 months of recognition as an eligible midwife; or the successful completion of:

an accredited and approved program of study determined by the Board to develop midwives’ knowledge and skills in prescribing, or

a program that is substantially equivalent to such an approved program of study, as determined by the Board.

My understanding of the above is that you can be deemed an eligible midwife and give the undertaking that you will complete within 18 months further study for prescribing and diagnostics.

Now we have to wait for the realise of the courses that we are to do...those from WA who have already completed the Eligible Midwife program which was four units...should get some RPL (recognition for prior learning).....
Until these units are established it seems that midwives are required yet again to jump through hoops to give continuity of care.....

the bottom line is that you will have to have three years experience across the continuum of midwifery before you can become an eligible midwife..... complete your Midwifery Practice Review and do further study.....oh and don't forget you need to be insured.....
We are the midwives paving the way for the future.... don't give up....lets beat the bastards and prove this can be done.....

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

A historic day today for Midwives in Australia


Today's legislation gives midwives the right to a Medicare number come the 1st November 2010, whether you are a supporter or not of the new legislation this is a monumental day… never in Australian history has such recognition be afforded to the profession of Midwifery.

It was good to listen to the proceedings in Parliament and hear the words 'midwife' 'midwifery' continuity of care' spoken so many times and in such a positive light and for the first time to hear the AMA take a bit of heat...it was truly exciting and it will be worth reading the transcript.......for prosperity...

The Health Legislation Amendment (Midwives and Nurse Practitioners) Bill 2009

The Midwife Professional Indemnity (Commonwealth Contributions) Bill 2009

I have thought long and hard about this legislation and despite its short falls I still think it is a good place to start. Recently I had the pleasure of meeting an esteemed midwifery blogger who introduced me to a new way of contemplating this legislation, that being: it is a ploy by the AMA to manipulate midwives and midwifery through the process of collaboration, that this is what the government had planned all along and we as midwives were lambs to the slaughter…….. Although I am open to this suggestion ….. I like to believe other wise that the Health Minister had the best interest of women and midwives in creating this step towards the emancipation of midwifery and midwives to provide woman centred informed choice…. the freedom of choice, place of birth for women and access to a named midwife.

The fight must go on to define the terms’ collaboration’ and also defining ‘eligibility’ what is the ‘eligible midwife’. Midwives have the right to work autonomously and not be controlled by doctors or obstetricians…… Midwives are the expert in the ‘normal’ process of birth…… Homebirth is not illegal it is a reliable choice for women, for which they should be given the option….. And not controlled by the medical model. Someone recently said to me “rules are meant to be questioned, we should not follow blindly” and our cause is one such case…… we need to stand up and be counted…..we as midwives have the right to birth women at home if it is the woman’s choice and it is safe for her to do so…… We must remain vigilant, posed ready for battle to defend this right…… and make sure that the government, doctors and anyone else that may wish to deter us from being able to provide women with the freedom to choose what health care want.

Monday, February 15, 2010

Anger due to cuts in private obstetricans fees

This is an interesting debate the cutting of costs for rebates in private health insurance. Previously women could claim 80 per cent of out-of-pocket obstetrics fees after reaching the safety-net threshold.
It is also interesting to see that low risk women are asked to attend local hospitals as opposed to mainstream high risk hospitals where the intervention rate is much higher. This is where we would benefit from having more birth centers, or midwives working out of hospitals within the community.
The question is will this push women to seek midwifery led care in low risk cases, as opposed to paying more to see a private obstetrician and risk the cascade of intervention..... and higher costs.
The recent newspaper article Anger over cut to obstetrics rebate discusses these issues, stating that in the current boom will we run out of beds in our hospitals.

What the article fails to mention is that midwifery led care in low risk women is a more affordable option and saves the tax payer millions of dollars.....

Monday, July 20, 2009

Would love to set something like this up in Perth!

The illawarra Mercury reported a feel good story about a "Midwifery Group Practice" that is doing well.

The Midwifery Group Practice, where the same midwives work with expectant mums before, during and after birth, is made up of nine midwives whose intake is supposed to be capped at 40 clients at a time.

The program is booked out for births until March 2010.


It is so good to read positive stories about homebirth and respecting women's choices about where and how women want to birth.

I would love to set up this sort of practice in WA and have it funded by the government and with the new legislation looming it is doubtful that we would get indemnity insurance to protect both the midwife and the woman.

Any ideas of how to make it work?



Reference:
First for home births
BY ANGELA THOMPSON
18/07/2009 4:00:00 AM

Save Homebirth

Home Birth Australia